The more things change, the more they stay the same, huh? Life in this here Modern Yoga World.
I’m coming out of self-imposed writing exile to write about Kausthub Desikachar again. The latest is that he trademarked the word “Viniyoga.” Here is his justification for the trademark. The word “viniyoga” is in the Yoga Sutra-s so it is as if Kausthub is trademarking the word “AUM.” Whaaat?! I’m told that he is already sending cease and desist letters to those using the word “Viniyoga.”
Leslie Kaminoff wrote his response to Kausthub’s trademarking. Leslie has said all that needs to be said about it, in my opinion. I won’t add anything else other than I believe it’s all ego on Kausthub’s part and extremely misguided. It would make more sense to trademark “Desikachar Yoga” like “Forrest Yoga” or “Bikram Yoga” or “Jois Yoga” but “Viniyoga” as a style? Since he does not have an heir to carry on the Krishnamacharya Yoga lineage (he has a teenage daughter from a first marriage who has no interest in yoga), maybe that is his reasoning? One can only speculate.
The ill will and anger he is creating is his own karma. It would not be the first time that shit rains down on a yoga teacher because of EGO. You can draw your own conclusions from both writings.
BY THE WAY, KAUSTHUB, I AM ALSO LINEAGE HOLDER
OF YOUR GRANDFATHER’S YOGA TRADITION.
JUST BECAUSE YOU TRADEMARKED A WORD
DOESN’T MAKE THAT LESS SO.
As for the #metoo movement, it affected me. Deeply. I have my own #metoo stories as a survivor but not from the yoga world. At the time I looked at the Facebook pages of certain yoga teachers who were accused of sex abuse to see if they came out to own their shit, to support women. Kausthub was one whose page I looked at. Nothing. Crickets. For those who need a reminder, this is the first piece I wrote about him in 2012. I also wrote about him here and here.
I know those who are currently studying with him in India and I respect their judgment. I am not going to disavow friendships because of whom they choose to study with. I also attended a workshop he taught last year in Dixon, IL given at a woman’s house because frankly, no Chicago area yoga studio will host him (that I am aware of.) That being said, John Friend has no shortage of workshop opportunities from what I hear so who knows if Kausthub will teach here in the future.
Quite honestly, I went because I was curious, to see if things had changed with him. I last saw Kausthub at length in 2006 in India. Kausthub was an arrogant albeit excellent, even brilliant, teacher. I previously wrote about him when he gave a lecture in one of my KYM intensives about 5 years later. At the Dixon IL weekend the wisdom teachings in the yoga tradition that I have studied for 10+ years were wonderful, but all weekend I felt that something wasn’t right, something felt off to me about him. Kausthub asked me if I wanted to bring students to his new school in Chennai as I had to KYM in 2013. I couldn’t and I wouldn’t. I also would no longer bring students to KYM either (given another “yoga war” which is another subject), however, I won’t tell people not to study there.
Now Kausthub says that Viniyoga (R with a circle around it) “honors women.”
I will leave that right here and you can digest it given all that went down in 2012. As Australian yoga studio owner, Nikola Ellis, asked, “What does Kausthub Desikachar have in common with Donald Trump and Harvey Weinstein? They’re all great supporters and defenders of women (and partial to trademarking).”
The stats he cites are just that. Stats. Everyone knows that yoga is practiced mainly by women and the majority of teachers are women. KHYF does not hold women higher merely because a high percentage of women study there.
Kausthub also mentions his mother. When I was in India in 2013 I was told that his mother was encouraging women to study with her son even during the uproar of the accusations against him.
Ironically Kausthub’s message about how he honors women arrived on the same day that Yoga Alliance published their new policy on sexual misconduct.
This morning I received this email. I don’t know who sent it (obviously someone who has my email address) or who the “concerned yoga teachers and women” are, but I believe the trademarking together with his statement on “honoring women” lit the flames of a long simmering seemingly unresolved outrage:
Kausthub Desikachar, son of TKV Desikachar and grandson of T Krishnamacharya, was reported to have abused numerous students in 2012. The allegations were extensive, pointing to serial and systemic misconduct, but were either covered up or not examined impartially.
Kausthub, and his organization, KHYF, are now aggressively promoting themselves through his family connection to his famous father and grandfather. He is offering program on topics closely related to his alleged abuses, such as granthis, shadow side of yoga etc.
He has also been registered by the Yoga Alliance recently.
More details here: https://saveyogasavewomen.org.
By sharing this and adding your voice to this message, you are doing the right thing. If the allegations have no foundation, then Kausthub will address the issue and clear himself. If there is truth to it, as we have significant reason to believe, then you will stop more people from being hurt.
Please share this email and our website. Speak up against serial and systematic misconduct. Support ethics and abuse prevention in yoga.
You can also write to the Yoga Alliance at: firstname.lastname@example.org
A group of concerned yoga teachers and women
I knew in my bones that as soon as the shit hit the fan with his trademark, that someone would again raise the topic of his sexual misconduct. It was only a matter of time. Some of the things I referred to in my posts in 2012 are also mentioned on this new website such as how KYM and long time teachers knew and did nothing. You can read all the links on the site.
As much as I abhor Kausthub’s actions from 2012, still think he has a massive ego, and his trademarking of the word “Viniyoga” is extremely misguided, I believe that anonymous attacks are questionable. When I wrote about Kausthub, I put myself on the line. When I reviewed his book on the Hatha Yoga Pradipika, I put my reputation on the line. When I attended the weekend workshop with him last year I put myself on the line because of what I wrote in 2012. I was accused of being an enabler by people who don’t know me and by some who do, none of whom knew anything about my reasons for doing his workshop last year. I am not responsible for what people think about me. My true friends never doubted me for a moment.
I understand the need for an outlet for victims/survivors.
During the #Metoo discussion I saw the face of my rapist in my mind’s eye daily.
But an anonymous website, should it be done that way? I don’t know and I am certainly not going to tell a victim/survivor what they should or should not do. You can draw your own conclusions about the “save yoga save women” website.
Kausthub will never see the inside of a courthouse. Instead, he will have to deal with the court of public opinion that can be more brutal than what happens inside a real courthouse.
Karma bites us all in the ass in one way or another. The Universe pushes us towards things we are supposed to do and things we are not supposed to do. Sometimes we go against our better judgment and do questionable things anyway. There are lessons in all of it. My teacher in Chicago just shrugs his shoulders and says, “Life.”
One thing I’ve come to realize in my old age is that there are no enlightened beings, only enlightened actions.